Blogger Template by Blogcrowds.

I strongly agree with the authors of this week's readings that "the ongoing, honest quest for information and understanding through the act of questioning," "student choice," and "balance" gets students deeply involved with texts and with exploring the nature of their own thinking (Copeland 7, Daniels 18, 27). These articles, like others we've read in this course, have encouraged me to expand my notion of what it is I will be doing as an English teacher. Socratic and literature circles, book clubs, and other strategies to get students discussing literature has me further considering what my teaching philosophy will be and what it is I want students in my classes to take away. Copeland's article best address, for me, what I would most like to see students walk away with - that is, skills that go far beyond simply knowing how to read and analyze text, but also skills in communicating thoughtfully with others, resolving conflict constructively, and building communities (19, 20, 21).

I have concerns about implementing these strategies into my classroom, however. First of all, I'm not sure I would be comfortable with these strategies until I was more familiar with the students I work with. While it is important to know your students personally in order to successfully facilitate these types of circles, it's also important to know the student group, generally. For example, I would want more experience with the types of questions and prompts that would work best with the age group I work with, and what books are most appropriate, and the best way to construct groups.

Further, I think to implement these strategies you need to be very confident in your abilities to control a classroom. Daniels reminds us that these literature circles require that there is "a decentralized classroom, lots of different books being read, and lots of logs and materials circulating, the frequent reshuffling of groups, plenty of noise and movement" and I think all of these things together would be very overwhelming to a newer teacher and things could get out of control quickly if the teacher didn't have lots of confidence and control. I don't imagine that right off the bat I will be confident allowing students to run their own dialogue. I would want a good amount of practice getting students comfortable with the skills needed, in a more controlled environment, before I would lead a circle like this.

Finally, I really think that these strategies probably work with very specific groups of students. Last week's reading by Delpit reminds us that students with different backgrounds approach education and the activities and strategies that teachers use very differently. For example, Daniels suggests that play and fun is an important aspect of the literature circles and I don't doubt that this is true. However, I think with certain groups of students, this kind of instruction and activity could be interpreted differently. For many students, the classroom is not "another kind of dining-room table," it is their ONLY dining-room table and these students likely come to the classroom with a very different relationship towards reading than other students, who have "playful interaction" with reading and writing at home would.

As I consider incorporating these strategies into my own classroom, Daniels' comments on fitting literature circles into a "balanced reading program" resonates with me. Especially when one considers the students who may not get scaffolding in reading and writing at home, it is important not to rely on these strategies too heavily. The authors of these articles do refer to scaffolding and modeling activities to help set students up for this kind of classroom experience, and that is obviously very important. However, it is possible that many students need more direct reading instruction and assistance.

Overall, I think these strategies introduce an interesting aspect of what a language arts classroom can provide and what it can look like.

0 comments:

Newer Post Older Post Home