I entered my first long-term teaching position after the regular teacher essentially disappeared. The job was a full-time English teacher for three classes of juniors and two classes of seniors in a large urban high school. Before I arrived, the students had been subjected to two months of having a different substitute nearly every day. There was no curriculum. No lesson plans. No classroom management system. The classroom was a cart. After the morning classes in a portable classroom out behind the main school building, the cart needed to be shoved (the cart was from the 1970s and a wobbly wheel did not help the endeavor) down a snowy ramp into the main building where the last two classes of the day were held in two different classrooms. The staff was nice and welcoming, but there were few resources and the administration seemed to go out of its way to make my existence seem like a hassle to them.
For the most part, the students were well-behaved, with such notable exceptions as the student who called me a bitch and told me a I was annoying and the boy who stormed out of class in a hail of cursing when I asked him to stop talking. And, on the whole, they were on the bright side. Again, with some notable, if not terribly depressing, exceptions (think: 12th graders who had never heard of a thesis statement before).
I applied for the position long-term. Even though the job was not ideal, it was still a job and those are hard to come by these days. But I didn't get it. I was told not to take it personally, that the reason I didn't get it was that there were sure to be cuts at the end of the year and since I am not tenured, I would certainly be cut. Of course, I was frustrated by this reasoning and made me even more adamant that tenure rules for teachers need to be altered, if not gotten rid of all together.
I loved this book. I finished this book in two sittings and I was sad when it ended. I wanted to stay with the characters and their lives; I really felt like I knew them and was invested in them. These are some of the most likeable characters I have come across in a long, long time. Liesel and Rudy’s relationship is absolutely precious and Papa and Mama are utterly loveable (yes, even Mama). The language and the structure of this story are absolute perfection. The layers and nuances, perspectives, and illuminations are stunning. I simply could not have enjoyed this book more. My mother is reading it now at my recommendation and many copies are being shipped to other family members and friends.
It took me a few tries to get into the book, based on the first few chapters. It took me a minute to figure out who the narrator was, and once I did figure it out, I went back and reread the first chapters, in order to be sure I caught everything. I was also a little tripped up with the bolded announcements. Overall, it was just a slow start, and I think I became a little daunted. Once I got into the story, however, I literally could not put it down. I stayed up until 3:00 in the morning finishing it and sobbing.
I was a kid who loved books and loved to read. My parents are voracious readers and encouraged my brothers and me to be, as well. I think that Liesel’s appetite for books, along with her boldness and passion, really allowed me to relate to her. And, I really am a softie for coming of age stories. I just loved watching her mature and come into herself as the story went on. The more comfortable she became in her family and the ownership she was able to have over it with the arrival of Max was very joyful.
My mother and I had an interesting conversation about Liesel’s initial relationship with her Papa. We both admitted that when Papa came into her room to comfort her, we became a little uneasy and were waiting for something to bad to happen. We both assumed that he was going to abuse or molest her! Isn’t that odd? That our first responses to a loving, comforting man approaching a young girl was that something awful was going to happen? Did the author intend to draw attention to the reader’s tendency to assume the worst when it comes to those things? Are we conditioned by TV, movies, and other stories that that is what happens in those situations? And that my mother and I both felt that way…interesting.
Not once while I was reading this did I feel like I was reading a story for young adults. There are so many layers and it is such a rich, sophisticated book, but so interesting and accessible, I believe it is a wonderful read for any reader at any age. I would have devoured this book when I was younger.
Critical Response
There a few elements to this story that I want to focus on in this critical response. The three factors that I believe contribute the most to the success of this novel are the structure, the narrator and general perspective, and the language. In this story, these three things strike me as so utterly original, poignant, and masterful that a critique without mentioning these things is useless.
The structure of the story is fascinating. Each chapter is named for a book that comes into Liesel’s life, which, we find out later, is what she did in her own book. I don’t normally care for tables of content in novels, but it was interesting that the beginning of each chapter also included a list of what the reader could expect in the coming chapter. Having a mysterious glimpse as to what was coming actually added an element of fun and surprise to the reading experience. In addition to the physical structure of the story, the way that various components of the story are revealed to the reader is very interesting. Max is introduced to us before we know how he is connected to the story. The reader knows how many books Liesel will steal, we know that she will be affected by the war, and we know that Rudy is going to die. Somehow, though, this doesn’t ruin anything, but rather compels the reader on. Only a masterful storyteller can give away so much information and still encourage his or her readers to keep on reading.
Of course, one cannot even think about this book with considering the narrator. Additionally, it is worth noting that this book about the Holocaust and World War II is not from the perspective of the Jews, or the soldiers, as many stories about this topic are. It is from the perspective of a German child who watches all of it swirl around her. But back to Death. This idea of giving the reader an omniscient narrator who also has a personality is fascinating. Personifying death gives the reader a narrator that they can relate to and imagine. In this story, Death has a sense of humor, a heart, a mind, and a job. At the same time, though, Death is literally everywhere and allows the reader an opportunity to think about death as a job that must be carried out and one that gets busier depending on how humans are treating each other. This technique really gives the reader a perspective on the damage and horror of war, possibly more than any other literary technique I’ve ever seen.
Zusak’s book is about books, so of course the language of the book needs to be masterful, and it is. One of the most stunning moments of this story is when we get to read the book Max writes for Liesel. Not only is the story itself lovely, heartbreaking, and poignant, but it is also such a beautifully complex example of the power of words and stories. The reader can actually see the words of Mien Kampf, a book that had the power to take millions of lives, but one that Max tells Liesel is “the best book ever,” because “it saved [his] life.” Max covers up the words of this powerful, awful book, and provides another one, much like the tree does in the second book he writes for her.
Zusak’s words are magnificent. His metaphors and imagery is fascinating. When Liesel is sitting on the floor of Ilsa Hermann’s library, her secret about Max bubbles to the surface of her mouth. Zusak writes, “[T]he secret sat in her mouth. It made itself comfortable. It crossed its legs.” He not only personifies death in this story, but words and many other things throughout the story. Overall, the language, the narrator, the characters, the relationships between the characters, and the structure come together to form one the most memorable books I’ve read in a long time.
This collection of poems really surprised me. I was not prepared for first person stories of insects. From the cover, I had a completely different sense of what was in store when I first started reading. At first, I was not convinced and I thought the poems were too elementary to be considered adolescent literature. After the third or fourth poem, though, I got into the rhythm of reading with the two voices in my head and I started the book over and I read with the title, Joyful Noise, in my head. After that, I read this collection like I was listening to classical music. It was a flow-like experience that really was joyful, serene, and very present. I felt like I was really there as I read. Sometimes when you read, you can check out a little and I didn’t do that with these poems at all.
These poems remind me of camping. In the summer, I work at a girl’s camp. Part of my job is to take 8 or 9 girls to the boundary waters for about 10 days for a canoe trip. I will take this book with me next summer. The concept of having two voices read together and the almost singsong feel to them makes this the kind of book that can be read around a campfire. There is a wonderful book called Paddle Whispers that we always bring with us on the trips and these poems really remind me of that. It also has the lovely simple pictures similar to the one in this book.
These poems really are about the beautiful noises of the little things in life. They are a reminder of all the small lives that are lived everywhere. They give voice to the hidden lives we often forget about. Often insects are thought of as nuisances or scary. These poems show the human side, as it were, to the lives of every living thing. That really is the kind of message we try to send to the girls on those trips.
Critical Response
It’s impossible to react to these poems without considering the structure. The fact that these poems are intended to be read out loud by two voices adds so much depth to these poems. How the poems are meant to be delivered to their audience and received by that audience is influenced by the structure and their meaning and significance are altered.
On one hand, the blatant expression of the author’s intentions has the initial effect of coming off like rules or boundaries. Most poems are delivered to their audience divorced from the presence of the author. The author’s intentions are irrelevant and interpretation is up to the reader. Literary theorist Roland Barthes, in his essay “Death of the Author” argues that “to give a text an “Author" and assign a single, corresponding interpretation to it "is to impose a limit on that text.” Additionally, for the middle or high school student, this expectation might seem elementary. This is an important concept to introduce to students as they learn how to approach texts and try to interpret them.
On the other hand, for the solitary, silent reader, knowing that the poems were meant to read with two voices adds a dimension to the reading that couldn’t be experienced without explicit instruction. As the reader makes their way down the page, the eye darts back forth and sometimes floats right down the center of the page, much like the jittery movements of an insect. Also, the reader experiences a kind of give and take in their mind. Suddenly, there is another reader present in the mind of the initial reader. Each reader has a different reading personality. Especially for a beginning or reluctant reader, realizing that there are different ways to read and that you can take on different reading personas is a valuable lesson.
Finally, the structure also offers an opportunity for readers to experience poetry orally. Poetry is often illuminated when it’s read out loud. The task of having to synchronize voices and rhythm is a good lesson in the internal workings of poetry.
Overall, I enjoyed this book for the opportunities it affords for a poetry lesson for middle or high school students as well as the opportunities it offers for interesting discussions on authorial intent and how to interpret texts.
I should probably begin my response to “Science Fiction Week” with the disclaimer that I was NOT looking forward to reading science fiction all that much. I’ve never had too much luck with it, with the big exception to that being anything I’ve ever read by Margaret Atwood. So, I was delighted when I got into The Hunger Games and discovered that I was completely absorbed with it to the point of staying up until 3:00 am to finish it, then immediately ordering the next two books in the series.
One of the reasons I like Margaret Atwood’s science fiction is that her stories are always set just on the edge of the world as we know it. Things that are happening now have gone on just a little longer and usually something has gone terribly wrong and the story is about the aftermath. The Hunger Games is just like that. I really did not have to stretch my imagination too far in order to buy into the story. In fact, all I really had to do was think of five or so reality TV shows that already exist, smash them together, and add some killing.
As with fantasy, I had some trouble getting into the story. I wasn’t really sure what was going on, and because I was a little prejudiced about the genre, I was prepared to not like it. It took me about halfway through the first section to really start anticipating the actual Hunger Games and appreciate all the commentary the story offered on a voyeuristic society with too much time on their hands, while other members of the society are exploited for resources and entertainment. And while Katniss took a little getting used to, by the time she was being interviewed in her glittering dress, I was completely invested in her story and was rooting for her to come around with Peeta, who was terribly likable from the beginning.
I thought the details of the actual Hunger Games were extraordinarily well thought out. Between the details regarding the sponsors, the faces being lit up at night, the cannons, etc., I was utterly absorbed. There was no doubt in my mind that this could be a real thing.
Critical Response
An aspect of this novel that really surprised me was the Katniss’ need for self-consciousness regarding the audience. One of the most defining parts of being an adolescent is the constant obsession with how others perceive you. Of course, if all teenagers are worried about how others see them, then there is no one left to actually care. In Katniss’ case, though, she really does have to be concerned with how others perceive her. She imagines the audience at home and how they will interpret her actions, intonations, and alliances. This element of the story provides interesting commentary on the nature of living in a voyeuristic society. If an audience is always there, how do we know what is real? As an adolescent novel, I think this and other questions that might arise from this story are terribly relevant for young people to consider. What is reality? Reality TV? What role does the concept of reality and its manipulation play in our identities?
Normally, I would consider some parts of this story somewhat elementary and simple. However, since is carries so much weight in the themes it brings up, it’s easy to overlook the simplicity of the language and character development. Additionally, when it comes to the characters, their personal development and the development of their relationships to each other, I think it best to reserve judgment until I’ve finished the other two books in the series.
This story really conveys the power of science fiction. I am completely converted and can see now what a powerful genre it is. Underneath and behind the parts of Panem that are unfamiliar is a world that is entirely too familiar. What we are left with is a portrait of a world we really could be on the brink of creating. In addition to providing us with a story about how we live now, Ms. Collins has also offered her audience a warning of where we might go if we don’t look critically at the world we’re living in and, perhaps, make some changes.
Labels: big brother, fiction, margaret atwood, science fiction, suzanne collins, YA Lit
It would be a little misleading to say that I “enjoyed” this book. In fact, it inspired something like hatred in me. I hated Titus, I hated the feed, and I hated how little I had to stretch my imagination in order to buy into this book. The amount of hatred I have towards this story is actually a compliment to Ms. Anderson, though. I think she wrote a science fiction/horror story that is so utterly compelling, thought provoking, and terrifying, that it’s good, which is bad. Am I making any sense?
It took me a while to get into this book, which isn’t surprising, given my general aversion to science fiction. The trip to the moon was not terribly convincing. Frankly, the whole space travel aspect of the story remains the weakest part for me. It makes the setting seem less believable. The language is painful, there isn’t a single likable character (with Violet and her father being only slight exceptions), and tells us of an awful, shallow, dead world that looks uncomfortably like our own, but all in a good way.
It’s impossible to read this book and not think about 1984. Big Brother has become the feed, but the characters in Anderson’s world are even more beholden to the hold of the feed, as their entire bodies are connected to it. It’s also impossible to read this book and not think about how much time we spend staring at screens, getting bombarded with ads. Especially kids. As I was reading this book, I kept seeing images of teenagers at dinner with their families, glued to their phones, texting, surfing, staring blankly. Really, is a microchip in the brain so far behind? Of course, it’s pretty unfair to accuse young people of being the only victims of the constant chatter. Adults are as addicted to their iPhones and laptops as are young people. I know I am guilty of spending a little too much time staring at screens.
Between this book and The Hunger Games, I am really stunned by the power of this genre. I can’t think of another book that has made me so angry and so inspired at the same time as these two did. I always thought science fiction was just for the imagination and that important messages about our lives and our worlds were absent from them. After reading these stories, I know this is far from true. In fact, it may be that there is more truth about our world in these stories than in stories with more realism.
Critical Response
This book is one of the best examples I’ve come across of how language can be manipulated and shaped to fit a story. For all the characters’ inability to articulate themselves, the language of this novel is what makes it what it is. Anderson has made up a whole set of slang words, which make absolute sense, and has managed to convey such powerful messages through a narrator that has almost no sense of self awareness. Through Titus’ cluelessness, we see the reality of his world. Within the scrambled mess of all the novel’s non-communication, a very poignant message comes through loud and clear. An important lesson about the power of language and that silence can be as communicative as speech is a valuable aspect of this story. Language, according to this novel, is both something that needs to be preserved and allowed to evolve and change.
The characters in this story are hugely unlikable. Titus’ parents are ridiculous, his friends even more so, and he himself is so completely damaged and unaware. However, it’s a tricky thing, because in some ways you have to feel sorry for these characters. After all, they are merely victims of time and circumstance. However, the interesting question about personal responsibility and agency must inevitably be asked in regard to these characters. If it is not their responsibility to question the world they live in and think independently, than whose is it? Imperfection, numbness, and the desire for escape are all running themes in this novel. The characters are all imperfect, as we all are, but are obsessed with being perfect. They are all searching for meaning and feeling, but end up feeling nothing. In an effort to feel something, they escape from their lives either through alcohol or malfunctioning. They don’t like their lives but try everything to change that. When that doesn’t work, they try the same thing again. One of the saddest, more disturbing moments of this story for me was when Titus goes home after visiting a comatose Violet and orders pants. His search for comfort came from purchasing things. In the end, Titus knows something is wrong, but he loves the feed.
Labels: big brother, fiction, fitting in, science fiction, YA Lit
