Blogger Template by Blogcrowds.

This collection of poems really surprised me. I was not prepared for first person stories of insects. From the cover, I had a completely different sense of what was in store when I first started reading. At first, I was not convinced and I thought the poems were too elementary to be considered adolescent literature. After the third or fourth poem, though, I got into the rhythm of reading with the two voices in my head and I started the book over and I read with the title, Joyful Noise, in my head. After that, I read this collection like I was listening to classical music. It was a flow-like experience that really was joyful, serene, and very present. I felt like I was really there as I read. Sometimes when you read, you can check out a little and I didn’t do that with these poems at all.
These poems remind me of camping. In the summer, I work at a girl’s camp. Part of my job is to take 8 or 9 girls to the boundary waters for about 10 days for a canoe trip. I will take this book with me next summer. The concept of having two voices read together and the almost singsong feel to them makes this the kind of book that can be read around a campfire. There is a wonderful book called Paddle Whispers that we always bring with us on the trips and these poems really remind me of that. It also has the lovely simple pictures similar to the one in this book.
These poems really are about the beautiful noises of the little things in life. They are a reminder of all the small lives that are lived everywhere. They give voice to the hidden lives we often forget about. Often insects are thought of as nuisances or scary. These poems show the human side, as it were, to the lives of every living thing. That really is the kind of message we try to send to the girls on those trips.

Critical Response

It’s impossible to react to these poems without considering the structure. The fact that these poems are intended to be read out loud by two voices adds so much depth to these poems. How the poems are meant to be delivered to their audience and received by that audience is influenced by the structure and their meaning and significance are altered.
On one hand, the blatant expression of the author’s intentions has the initial effect of coming off like rules or boundaries. Most poems are delivered to their audience divorced from the presence of the author. The author’s intentions are irrelevant and interpretation is up to the reader. Literary theorist Roland Barthes, in his essay “Death of the Author” argues that “to give a text an “Author" and assign a single, corresponding interpretation to it "is to impose a limit on that text.” Additionally, for the middle or high school student, this expectation might seem elementary. This is an important concept to introduce to students as they learn how to approach texts and try to interpret them.
On the other hand, for the solitary, silent reader, knowing that the poems were meant to read with two voices adds a dimension to the reading that couldn’t be experienced without explicit instruction. As the reader makes their way down the page, the eye darts back forth and sometimes floats right down the center of the page, much like the jittery movements of an insect. Also, the reader experiences a kind of give and take in their mind. Suddenly, there is another reader present in the mind of the initial reader. Each reader has a different reading personality. Especially for a beginning or reluctant reader, realizing that there are different ways to read and that you can take on different reading personas is a valuable lesson.
Finally, the structure also offers an opportunity for readers to experience poetry orally. Poetry is often illuminated when it’s read out loud. The task of having to synchronize voices and rhythm is a good lesson in the internal workings of poetry.
Overall, I enjoyed this book for the opportunities it affords for a poetry lesson for middle or high school students as well as the opportunities it offers for interesting discussions on authorial intent and how to interpret texts.

0 comments:

Newer Post Older Post Home