Satrapi, Marjane. Persepolis: The Story of a Childhood. Paris: Pantheon Books, 2003.
Persepolis is the true story, told as a graphic novel, about a young girl growing up in revolutionary Iran. Marji is confused and intrigued by all the things happening around her. The messages her parents send are contradictory and convoluted, some people are considered heroes, others deserve to die, and others still deserve forgiveness and it’s all very hard to keep straight for a young girl with so much happening around her. Each chapter of this story relates an aspect of the Iranian revolution that began in the late 1970’s. Throughout them all, Marji is trying to reconcile her family’s revolutionary ideas with the realities of social classes. She is also working through normal childhood dreams about being related to a prince, desires for attention from her distracted parents, and the search for a real-life hero to look up to.
The graphics are all black and white and look vaguely like sophisticated children’s drawings. The stark visuals suggest the strict divisions between various schools of thought in Iran. Everyone seems to consider themselves right and everyone else wrong, with little room for grey areas. This is a wonderful story, emotional and gripping, that tells the story of a place that is often misrepresented. This look into Iran reveals truths about this part of the world that we often wish we could overlook. This is a book about war, fear, love, loyalty to home and family, and is told through graceful illustrations that convey emotion and evoke sympathy and compassion.
Labels: graphic novel, memoir, middle east, multi-cultural literature, non-fiction, YA Lit
I didn’t really know what to expect with this book. This was one of my first experiences with a graphic novel and I had mixed emotions about it. I sense that I am responding to the book as much for its genre as for its content, since I am still sorting out how I feel about graphic novels. As of now, I am thinking that the graphic novel is a wonderful way to encourage reluctant readers, offers a lot of opportunity for classroom activity, and is very entertaining. However, I fear that it could also be criticized for undermining reading or seen as being condescending. A successful graphic novel can be more of a benefit for the classroom than a deterrent, so the graphic novel deserves careful treatment.
I really enjoyed the way this book intersects Chinese myth and present-day concerns. Many young people of all backgrounds tend to disregard the myths and legends of their ancestors as outdated and un-relatable. However, by presenting the Monkey King story in cartoon form and sprinkled with humor, it suddenly becomes modern and relevant. I also really like the aspects of this story that could not have been told without the illustrations, such as Jin’s transformation into Danny and Danny’s “cousin” Chin-Kee.
I struggled through the parts with Chin-Kee. Of course, I understand the use of hyperbole and irony, but it is still uncomfortable to read through such blatant stereotyping. Once, though, everything comes together in the end, I realized how effective that character was. But, again, Yang’s portrayal should be carefully dealt with in a classroom situation.
Critical Response
This book deals with themes and issues related to stereotyping and discrimination, on a personal level and in popular culture. The book begins with Chinese myth and hooks the reader with humor and action. The other two stories, of Jin and Danny, seem unrelated, both to the Monkey King story and to each other. The reader grows a little suspicious when Danny’s Chinese cousin Chin-Kee visits. The reader never sees Danny’s parents and Danny himself doesn’t appear to be Chinese, so his relation to Chin-Kee is suspect.
The dialogue and illustrations are very entertaining and engaging, even believable. The interaction between Jin and his new teacher introducing him to the classroom is very funny and the look on Timmy’s face when he raises his hand to ask about whether Chinese people eat dog or not is spot on. Frankly, it is laugh out loud funny. But the humor is, of course, tongue-in-cheek – it’s funny because it’s a little too true and we’ve all seen situations just like it. And this is where this book and books like it are so successful. They deal with serious issues without taking themselves too seriously.
The ending of the book was slightly troubling. I thought it was a little too convenient and continued to exploit a number of stereotypes, but in ways I found more difficult to explain away. For example, Wei-Chen’s transformation into a thug bothers me. However, the overall messages – accepting yourself as you are and realizing that the people you may want to be like are not worth being like – are worthy and powerful.
Wow. This book blew me away. I expected that I would like it, but I didn’t think it would affect me the same way a book with words affects me. But it did. In some ways, it was even more emotional as a graphic novel without words than it would have been with them.
There were a few panels that really moved me. The first one that I really noticed was towards the beginning, when the man is getting on the train and there is a close-up of his hands holding his wife’s and child’s hand and then they let go. It’s such a small, simple detail that conveys the situation really well. The reader (viewer?) senses what is happening and experiences the separation. Up to this point in the story, I actually thought the whole family was leaving. This was the panel where I learned he was leaving his family behind.
The next panel I enjoyed had all the pictures of the clouds, indicating the amount of time he had been on the boat. I found this an interesting way to communicate this, as one can imagine that all that time on a boat, one of the only ways to mark how time is passing is to just watch the weather. The author does the same thing towards the end of the story, where we see a small plant going through the growth stages of a year. Again, for a lonely man in an unfamiliar world, watching the seasons pass would be the only way to see time passing without his family.
Even without dialogue or narrative, I became very emotionally invested in this character. The way his emotions were conveyed – his loneliness, confusion, and desperation – almost entirely through illustrations of his face, and I was really drawn in.
Critical Response
This is an emotional book, with a lot of purpose. It very successfully conveys the loneliness and confusion of moving to a new place without knowing the language or the people. Many people could relate to this story and the way that it is told – through pictures only – is a big reason for this. The author obviously has a lot of sympathy and compassion for his character, but the story wouldn’t have been quite as moving without the illustrations. This is a familiar story told in an unfamiliar way and that is its strength.
Various details of what it is like to be away from home and loved ones are conveyed through the pictures that would have been very difficult with words. When the man first opens his suitcase, his first impression is that it is all that he has left of home and he sees his wife and daughter at the table without him, before turning back into his clothes and the picture he brought of them.
Another successful aspect of this story is that the author keeps the reasons for why the man and other refugees left their countries somewhat ambiguous. Some of the illustrations suggest familiar evils that have resulted in the displacement of many people, but as readers, we are left with our own interpretations. This same ambiguity applies to the city where the man finds himself. Of course, there are many aspects of this city that imply New York City, but the way the author doesn’t make anything explicit allows the reader to experience the same level of discomfort and alienation that the man does.
Overall, this was a very successful book about feeling like an outsider, finding one’s way, trusting in others, and maintaining hope in a hostile situation. The man’s little pet, for me, represents the ability in each of us to adjust to any situation and comfort ourselves when things are difficult.
Labels: fiction, fitting in, graphic novel, immigration, YA Lit
Clare, Cassandra. The Mortal Instruments Book One: City of Bones. New York: Simon Pulse, 2007.
The City of Bones is a fantasy tale that tells the story of Clary Fray and her introduction into the Clave, a world of Shadowhunters, vampires, werewolves, and other demons, witches, and warlocks. Clary is just a normal teenager, doing normal teenage things, and having normal teenage problems with her mom. Things change, though, when she witnesses an odd murder in the back room of a Manhattan club. Since no one else appears to see what she does, she convinces herself that she was just seeing things. The next night, though, after a big fight with her mom, Clary runs into Jace, one of the people she saw in the back of the club. Jace begins to explain to her that he is a Shadowhunter, a kind of soldier of the underworld, charged with protecting humans from vampires, werewolves, and other demons.
Things get even crazier when Clary learns that her mother has been abducted by demons and being held by Valentine, a rogue former Shadowhunter. After Clary is attacked by a ravener demon, Jace takes her to The Institute, where she meets Hodge, Isabelle, and Alec and learns that her mother used to be a Shadowhunter, which means she has Shadowhunter blood. As Clary and Jace set out on a quest to find Clary’s mother, they encounter hipster demons, crazed vampires, and protective werewolves. But Clary also learns more about her mother’s former life as a Shadowhunter, who her real father is, why the mortal cup is so important to Valentine, and why he thinks Clary’s mom has it. She also begins to tap into her own Shadowhunter.
I found it hard to get into this book, which I expected, since I don’t typically read fantasy books, but once I did, I was addicted. The story is quite gripping and believable. I was engaged with the characters, even when I found them unlikable (especially because I don’t think they’d be unlikable to teenagers). My biggest problem with this book is that there isn’t much purpose to it. Even with stories that take place in alternate realities and fantasy worlds, I think the story should be important and provide readers with life lessons. This book, though, doesn’t really teach anything. Even still, I think it’s a good book that adolescents would like. And not every book we read has to be vital.
This book would appeal to readers who typically like stories like this one – vampires, werewolves, etc. But young readers who like adventure hero stories or just need something gripping would enjoy this story. This book would engage a reluctant reader. The characters are fairly well developed and have pitch-perfect teenage attitudes and angst. The world the characters are operating in is fully developed, with a past, present, and future. There is intrigue, love, and mystery in this story, and the good news is that there are two more books in the series.
1.
Lowry, Lois. The Giver. New York: Delacorte Press, 1993.
In a world where everything is controlled and regulated, a young boy, Jonas, is selected to become the next Receiver of Memory. His training begins by meeting the current Receiver whose job it is to give Jonas memories from the world before it was the way it is. The more Jonas learns, the more isolated he becomes from his family and community. Once he learns what really happens to certain young people and the old, it becomes too much and he makes an important, life changing decision. Recommend to mature readers. Science fiction.
2.
Cisneros, Sandra. The House on Mango Street. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1984.
Esperanza tells about her childhood living in a house on Mango Street in a series of 1-3 page vignettes. A portrait of a dynamic and unique neighborhood emerges from stories about a bag of shoes, interesting thrift shops, a first job, the origins of a name, and late night phone calls from Mexico. This collection of stories is a beautiful, simple, quiet example of how one is shaped by and shapes where they come from. Told mostly from a child’s point of view, these stories of the personal and familiar, ends up portraying the universal and the unfamiliar. Recommended for all adolescent readers with reading skills from intermediate to advanced. Multi-cultural literature.
3.
Erdoes, Richard and Alfonso Ortiz, Eds. American Indian Trickster Tales. New York:
Penguin Books, 1998.
This collection of stories relates the adventures of Native American tricksters. The trickster shows up in virtually every American Indian body of lore and folk tales. He shows up in a variety of shapes and sizes and he is somehow involved in almost every kind of story – creation stories, death stories, stories of marriage, children, trickery, and magic. The trickster was a very important figure in Native American lore. He teaches young people about how the world was created, and through his misadventures, teaches how one ought to behave. This is a somewhat academic collection that wouldn’t be terribly interesting to an adolescent reader. The stories would be more effective with pictures or with the morals presented more explicitly. Present to adolescents in pieces, not as an entire collection. Folktales.
4.
Hoose, Phillip. Claudette Colvin: Twice Toward Justice. New York: Farrar, Straus and
Giroux, 2009.
This is the true story of Claudette Colvin, a young woman who fought back against the unfair treatment of blacks in Montgomery even before Rosa Parks did. In fact, her actions set the stage for Rosa Parks to be able to have the effect she did. This book includes first person interviews as well as narrative from other sources. There are a number of interesting and engaging photos that allow the reader to understand the Jim Crow laws that were in effect in the south at the time. It is very interesting to read about how the citizens and activists plotted the bus boycott as a result of Claudette’s actions. However, there are moments in Claudette’s recounting of the events that border on bitter that she did not garner the attention that Ms. Parks did. Instead of focusing on how well planned and clever the boycott was, it seems like Ms. Colvin has a chip on her shoulder about it. It is important to understand the time that these things were taking place and any kind of agitation in regards to the laws had to be precise and careful. Offer to students with a foundational knowledge of the time and place and intermediate to advanced reading skills. Nonfiction.
Out of the Dust is the story of young Billie Jo Kelby, a child of the Oklahoma dust bowl. Billie Jo tells her story in the first person through a series of free verse vignettes or poems. She starts to tell her story in the winter of 1934, beginning in August of 1920. In her first stark poem, Billie Jo introduces the reader to herself, her mother, father, and their circumstances. The first line presents the reader with the haunting voice she uses throughout the narrative: “As summer wheat came ripe,/so did I,/born at home, on the kitchen floor./Ma crouched,/barefoot, bare bottomed/over the swept boards,/because that’s where Daddy said it’d be best” (3). Her lines are as desolate as the landscape in which she lives.
Billie Jo paints a picture of what life was like in the dust bowl of the 1930’s. Her best friend, Livie Killian, moves away to California, money is tight, and people are killing rabbits to feed their families. In addition, Billie Jo’s mother is pregnant. But then, we learn how Billie Jo survives the depression and the gray, lonely “sea of dust” that envelopes their lives (33). She plays the piano. The verse she uses to communicate her playing mimics the jumpy, upbeat way in which she plays:
When I point my fingers at the keys,
the music
springs right out of me.
Right hand
playing notes sharp as
tongues,
telling stories while the
smooth
buttery rhythms back me up
on the left.
The very placement of the words on the page recreates the story she tells with her piano. She is good and she loves to play. It is her escape and her pride. The barren prose parallels the bleak landscape and in the moments we’re meant to catch a glimpse of comfort and cheer, the prose shifts. In the poem, “Dazzled,” Billie Jo describes her mother with a richness, density, and wholeness we haven’t yet seen in her narrative. When she describes her piano playing, the words bounce about like fingers on piano.
By the time the story’s climax arrives, which includes significant loss and injury –inside and out – the reader is invested in Billie Jo’s predicament and engaged in the story. The world in which Billie Jo is trapped can be felt and experienced in a rather visceral way, because of the wonderfully precise and deliberate language. Out of the Dust is a magnificent example of how the use of language and even its physical placement on the page can develop character, setting and plot. Additionally, it is an interesting examination of how one’s home and their position in history becomes an aspect of their identity. In the end, the story is really about a young girl’s strength and self-discovery in the face of suffocating devastation and isolation.
This story does a nice job of introducing the reader to a time and place in history that is very specific, but also providing a glimpse of the universal human experience and teaching lessons that are still relevant today. This book would make a wonderful companion to The Grapes of Wrath as a way of introducing the harsh realities of the 1930’s Oklahoma dust bowl.
Labels: 1930s, blank verse, dust bowl, historical fiction, YA Lit
I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this story. Truth be told, I was downright inspired by this book. The other night, I was finishing Shipwreck in my apartment, wrapped in a wool blanket because it was a little chilly, trying to imagine what it must have been like to be so cold, and so wet, and so hungry for so long. A few summers ago, I spent ten days canoeing and camping in the boundary waters. At one point, we had to portage our way through muskeg – a mixture of mud and water not unlike quicksand – that came up to our waists. Through this, I had to go back and forth, carrying four canoes on my shoulders, Duluth packs, and food crates. It was unbearably hot and muggy, and you could almost not see through the black flies that were feasting on any exposed skin they could find. At the time, it was the most uncomfortable I could remember being in a long time. And that ordeal lasted all of 45 minutes. Clearly I am a huge wimp, but needless to say, I was blown away by these men’s adventure.
I am not a non-fiction fan. It’s not that I don’t like non-fiction; I do and I wish I liked it more. It’s just that I get a little bored with it. I usually feel like I am reading a textbook and while I’m reading, I find myself gazing longingly at the novels on my shelves. That being said, I am fully aware of how much non-fiction can offer and even more aware of how necessary it is to have good non-fiction in a classroom. My brother, for example, loves non-fiction and is pretty much all he reads. But he wasn’t a big reader when he was younger and I asked him about this recently. He told me that he wasn’t exposed to books he really enjoyed until he got to college. For him, reading meant novels and he was just not into them. But once he got his hands on great non-fiction, he was addicted. So, I appreciate that non-fiction is a genre that is an access point for many readers and depriving them of it when they are young would be a terrible waste.
Critical Response
Shipwreck at the Bottom of the World is a textbook example of good non-fiction (pun intended). Jennifer Armstrong has incorporated all of the elements into her story that are essential for a story to be captivating and believable. The story incorporates records from the men’s journals and is very specific with the dates things occurred and times things happened. Charts, maps, lists, and photographs bring dimension to the story and allows the readers to physically engage with it.
The opening section, “Just Imagine,” brilliantly captures the audience’s attention. The descriptions of Antarctica are vivid and convey the hostility of the land. Armstrong writes, “The ice never melts; it clings to the bottom of the world, spawning winds, storms, and weather that affects the whole planet.” Her use of words like “clings” and “spawns” articulate how violent and inhospitable the place is. The impression of this continent being at “the bottom of the world” reminds readers of its isolation, but its ability to affect the weather of the entire planet is also a reminder of its strength. Finally, this section foreshadows the events in the book. In another kind of book, the revelation that no one dies on the exploration might be a giveaway that ruins the story. But in this case, the outcome is not as important as the journey itself. An adventure story is about the adventure. Further, most readers of non-fiction adventure stories would know enough to realize that no one would be writing a book about it if it wasn’t sensational and had a miraculous ending.
In no time, Armstrong has her readers on Endurance with the men, invested in their journey. She portrays the men as immensely likeable, which it seems they truly were. Incorporating stories that reveal their characters allows the readers to become familiar in a more intimate way with them. For example, the story of how The Boss deals with the stowaway reveals him to be tough, but kind and generous. The reader is able to follow their trek using the map at the beginning of the book and anticipate what might happen next by comparing dates on the map with the dates in the story. The reader is engaged and invested.
The pictures in this book really enhanced the reading experience. The pictures themselves were often startlingly beautiful and really capture the stark beauty and isolation of Antarctica. The reader can really close their eyes and try to imagine this ordeal. Especially pictures of the various camps, how the stoves were set up, how the ice latched onto them, and how they latched onto the boats as they dragged them through the ice, allow the reader to picture things that would otherwise be difficult to imagine. The book could have included a few pictures or diagrams of how the floes and bergs moved and swelled and how the ice managed to crush Endurance. For someone not familiar with how those things work, a visual aid would be helpful.
Overall, this book nicely captures an amazing adventure, but is also a powerful example of leadership, teamwork, endurance, bravery, and patience. It is not just an engaging story, but provides readers with valuable life lessons.
Labels: adventure, non-fiction, YA Lit
This book kind of blew my mind. I was really skeptical about it at first, but once I got into it, I could not put it down. I wasn’t totally convinced I liked fantasy fiction after reading The Graveyard Book, but this one has me converted. I was completely engaged in it, totally invested in Cameron, Dulcie, Gonzo, and Balder, and utterly mesmerized by the enormity of the content and landscape. Leaving this book was like leaving The Book Thief. I did not want to leave the characters, who have begun to feel like new friends that I want to get to know better.
I’m not sure how I would have liked this book as a teenager. I didn’t really like books like this when I was younger, but I think that was a personal thing, and I could see teenagers being really engaged with it. I think the audience for this book is important to how it is received. I could see a good many teens and adults being utterly confused by this book. How many kids would make the connection between CESSNAB and the pep rally Cameron’s school throws for him? The ones who would are, first of all, probably a lot like Cameron, and would also really enjoy this book’s satirical attitude. But, then again, I think people who don’t make connections like that in this book could still enjoy it. The book’s clever critique of the American landscape is subtle and poignant and I think that even when the significance of some aspects of the story aren’t immediately clear to the reader, they are still meaningful.
I was reminded of Tom Robbins while reading this book. I remember when I first picked up Still Life with Woodpecker thinking how in the world he was going to pull off a story set in a pack of Camel cigarettes, and being so stunned with surprise and awe when it came off so well. I felt the same way about this book. After reading the jacket summary, I was really curious and skeptical about how Bray was going to pull off a good, believable story about a kid with mad cow disease, a punk-rock angel, a yard-gnome, cults, etc., but around every corner of this story, I was stunned at the ease with which she maneuvered me into believing everything that was happening, doubting that it was a hallucination, and convinced that Cameron and Co. would find a cure and all would be well.
Critical Response
Sometimes when adult authors adopt the voice of a contemporary young person and tries to make it sound hip, current, and catchy, it comes off sounding forced and cheesy. However, the language in this book – dialogue, internal monologue, etc. – seemed very realistic. The characters were infused with a clumsy teenaged confidence that wavered at times and puffed out occasionally. The cadences were nicely conveyed with the use of ellipses, italics, commas, and pauses, which makes the language much more authentic. Bray did not shy away from using curse words and slang, which, again added authenticity and infuses the book with a quiet nod of respect towards young people and their worlds. She does this further by allowing her characters to act like real teenagers. They swear, drink, smoke pot, have sex, disobey authority figures, etc. but they are still good kids. By offering a realistic portrait of teenage life, Bray legitimizes adolescence and acknowledges the power of youth to invent language, rediscover reality, and question everything.
The adults in this book were portrayed refreshingly evenly. At first, we see Cameron’s parents the way most teenagers see their parents – flawed, out-of-touch, obstacles. But as he gets sicker and flashbacks to when he was younger and catches snippets of what they are going through watching him die, he starts to see them as real people who are trying their best and dealing with life as it comes to them, too. Bray is able to portray Cameron’s family sympathetically mostly because, under the drama, flair, and craziness that is the bulk of the story, this is actually a very sad story. Cameron is dying; he is in pain and fading away and his family is watching this. Character’s humanity comes through when they go through something painful and raw. Writing a sad, painful, raw story for teenagers that also has a lesson to it is not an easy task, but this is a successful adolescent coming-of-age story that manages to teach some things, is funny and sad all at once.
The most successful aspect of this story, for me, was it’s ability to keep the reader compulsively turn the page to literally find out what happens. It confidently straddles the line between totally unbelievable and utterly believable. The reader knows this has to be a hallucination, but still turns the page to make sure and figure out how Cameron’s going to get well and not die. When he does, it’s really sad.
Labels: big brother, fantasy, fiction, YA Lit
I really don’t like reading fantasy fiction. I have a hard time getting into it and buying into it. This book was no different. I had a really hard time getting into it and found myself not buying into it a lot in the beginning. And while this is certainly not my favorite book we’ve read so far, it definitely did a lot to change my perception of fantasy fiction. In the end, I really enjoyed this book and feel it has much to offer an adolescent reader. It satisfied all the major requirements of fantasy and, overall, I felt it was captivating and interesting.
Reading this book reminded me a little of reading The Secret Garden. This was one of my favorite books when I was young. One of the things I liked so much about it was the sense of lush, outdoors adventure, which this book had a lot of. I loved the descriptions of Bod wandering through the graveyard after reading Thackeray’s book, or creeping around Potter’s Field. The details of the woods and the land gave me a feeling of being there and being able to sense the isolation and out-of-this-worldliness of the story. I think this setting is a nice compliment to the often barren and isolating world of a typical adolescent. Perhaps it is a nice compliment, also, to the often barren and isolating world of being an adult? One reason I think I often avoid reading fantasy is that certain adolescent longings and feeling do surface from reading it, which makes me feel a little uncomfortable, at first. Once I enter that world, though, I find I enjoy it and lose myself in it, somewhat. But there is something uncomfortable in this comfort: do I long for my own adolescence? Do I have unresolved issues lingering from that time in my life? Or, more probably, do we all harbor longings and unresolved issues from this important, formative period in our lives and are we simply conditioned, as we age, to suppress those things and pretend that they don’t exist in an attempt to convince ourselves and/or others that we’re well-adjusted adults not in need of revisiting our youth? I think these are important questions to consider as adults approaching adolescent literature, particularly fantasy; for as we age, it becomes more difficult to suspend disbelief and enter, in a meaningful way, a world different from our own. In any event, this book was enjoyable to me on an adult level as well as an adolescent one.
Finally, I was pleasantly surprised by how compelling the question of where the borders between the living and the dead reside. I think it’s a difficult task for a writer to tackle the issue of death and force their readers to consider the afterlife and what it means to live a meaningful life. This effort can easily come off as condescending, trite, or preachy. This story, though, delicately managed to allow the reader to consider these questions in their own way.
Critical Response
Reading and responding to the literature we’ve read in this course so far, I have learned to approach the characters more like an adolescent than as an adult and to think about certain characterizations from their point-of-view rather than my own. For example, when I was reading Waiting for Alaska, I was not convinced of the characterization of The Eagle. I thought he was wildly underdeveloped and misrepresented. The comments I received for my critique urged me to consider his role from an adolescent’s perspective rather than from an adult’s. I think I brought that perspective to a reading of the “adults” – alive and dead – in this story. I think that Bod’s caretakers were wonderfully developed for a young audience. They were appropriately seen from the point-of-view of a six-year-old, eight-year-old, ten-year-old, etc. Additionally, Gaiman managed, by virtue of the genre in which he is working, to put distance between actual adults and the adults in his novel. On the one hand, he somewhat tongue-and-cheek implies that adults sometimes seem like they are 900 years older than young people, but he also manages to suggest that an actual adolescent’s authority figures aren’t that out of touch.
Bod’s development was equally well developed. His actions and perceptions were appropriate at each stage of his growth. When he was younger, things seemed far more mysterious, shrouded, and confusing. As he aged, he was able to make more sophisticated assumptions and conclusions about what was going on around him. This culminated in his final showdown with the Jacks and his ability to put all that he had learned together and take care of himself (even if this whole sequence was a little rushed and cliché).
This story introduced history as relevant, obscure, and mysterious, seamlessly. Bringing history and issues regarding how history is recorded and passed on into an engaging adolescent book is not a simple task. A reluctant reader who, for example, might utterly shun historical novels could take this book and be asked to consider how history might be told differently from the people who lived it versus how it is delivered in textbook form and actually think about it!
I was quite moved by this book. I thought it was written with a really stark honesty that addressed a lot of the realities of how a teenager would deal with this issue. I was worried going into a reading of this book that the issue would be idealized, glorified, or glossed over. This book did none of those things. I have one trans friend, well, more like an acquaintance. He is a she-to-he trans and even though I have been hugely supportive of his transition, I have really struggled to completely understand it. Since we’re not too good of friends, I felt uncomfortable asking too intimate questions. But I saw his voice deepen dramatically, begin fundraising for breast-reduction surgery, and generally turn into a guy, and I have been really curious about the process. I have tried to do research on the Internet and get mostly scientific information about hormones and surgeries, which are informative to an extent, but what I was really curious about was what this whole process is really about. I understand it in straightforward terms, but what about the day-to-day realities? That was what I’ve been after, and this book provided me with a lot of insight into what I’ve been wondering about. Issues of gender and sexual orientation are becoming much less taboo and so we know that adolescents are aware of these realities and there is no way they don’t have questions about them. If I do, they do. This book provides me with a vocabulary and a perspective, which makes addressing this issue and asking my friend questions much easier. I genuinely think that the sensitivity this book shows this issue can provide kids with these tools, too.
Critical Response
A book dealing with an issue like this takes on the enormous task of having to challenge people to relate to a situation that is likely very foreign to them. For the readers who can relate, it takes on the additional challenge of having to portray a delicate issue that still has a lot of stigma associated with it in a way that is not condescending, over-simplified, or in a way that will perpetuate stereotypes and prejudice. That is a difficult line to walk. The way the story oscillates between current action and flashbacks helps accomplish this job. Readers can easily relate to the current action: the horrors of high school, parents, feeling different. Even if a teen isn’t dealing with this particular issue, chances are they are or have dealt with something that they wanted to hide from others, or made them feel like they stick out. The flashbacks help the reader who is unfamiliar with this situation understand the inherent nature of being transgender. When Regan remembers young Liam asking his mom to “take it [his penis] off,” the reader is instantly struck by the confusion that must go on in the mind of someone who feels they weren’t born right. Regan’s voice is very natural and believable. She is the perfect combination of sassy, smart, witty young woman and self-conscious, awkward teenager. She is a rare teen narrator that is pretty reliable. She is probably at her most authentic when she is screaming and questioning things in her own mind. After Liam is caught dressing up at the Materas’ house, her feelings really start bubbling to the surface. “Everything I remembered about me interleaved with Liam. His life. Her struggle. Where were my memories? Where was my life?” These emotions are so real and I suspect that any younger sibling feels like this sometimes. The real humanity of the story comes out when Regan struggles with her love for her brother and her desire to be independent. Every teenager has to, at some point, reconcile family and self and we see Liam/Luna do this too. He/she does see his dependence on Regan and has to reconcile his fears and desires. One might argue that having the story of Luna told from the point-of-view of her sister is something of a cop out. However, this point-of-view actually enhances the humanity and universality of the story. Having the story told from Luna’s perspective could have alienated the reader from the entirety of the experience of dealing with something so substantial. If had been told by Luna, the reader might not have noticed how this issue relates to them. Having it come from Regan, the reader recognizes that someone close to them, in their family, at school, or next-door might be dealing with something like this. This perspective is important for young readers to recognize. Young trans readers might come away from a reading of this recognizing that there are other people out there like them and that there are ways of dealing with it, places for them to go, and people to talk to.
Labels: fiction, GLBT, multi-cultural literature, realistic fiction, YA Lit
There were two things I especially liked in this book. The first was the pictures. When I was flipping through the book, before I started it, I thought the pictures looked a little amateurish, but I found that they added a lot to the stories once I began reading them. The other thing I really liked was the natural, colloquial tone of them. I could really hear the voice in my head and I felt like I was sitting on a porch stoop in the South listening to an old grandma tell all the stories of her childhood. The stories told in the Gullah dialect appealed to me the most. My favorite stories were, “Bruh Alligator Meets Trouble,” “The Beautiful Girl of the Moon Tower,” “The Two Johns,” “John and the Devil’s Daughter,” “A Peculiar Such Thing,” “Better Wait Till Martin Comes,” and “The People Could Fly.”
The book I purchased was used from an Amazon.com dealer and it was once in a school library. It is wrapped in protective plastic and has a California school library stamp on the inside. It also has a pocket on the inside cover with the borrow card still in it. You can tell it’s a well-used book and this information is confirmed by the number of people who checked it out between the years of 1989 and 1999. On the outside and again on the inside cover there is a DISCARD sticker. I don’t know why all this information added so much to my reading experience, but it did. I think it has something to do with the idea of having resurrected a book from destruction or oblivion. It is a reminder that these are important stories that should not be forgotten. They are the voice of our history and culture. The book’s history seemed to help connect me to the history within it.
Critical Response
This book has such a unique style to it that successfully draws the reader in. The easy way that each story is introduced, such as, “Heard tell about Doctor Rabbit and Brother Fox,” or “Let’s talk about one time,” makes the reader feel at ease because the story seems more accessible. The colloquial tone of the stories helps that too. In the story “Bruh Alligator and Bruh Deer,” the narrator asks the reader, “How Bruh Deer gone get across go see his family?” This sense that the reader is being spoken to and that they are intimate with the narrator makes the stories themselves more intimate. The reader can hear the voice telling the story. The stories are told just the way they’d be told to a child or room full of people after a meal. In the story “The Peculiar Such Thing,” the narrator inserts an opinion and exclamation, just as one would if they were telling a story about something that happened to them at the store that day. “This fellow, like he had no sense, he cooked the great, big, long tail. Yes, he did. It tasted sweet and he ate it. Goodness!” You can just hear the giggles and twitters of young children as this is told to them.
The layout and order of the stories was very conducive to this collection of stories. Beginning with the stories about animals allows the reader a gentle entrance to the stories. Many people reading this might not be familiar with the style or content of stories like these, but most every culture has animal stories. This is something a reader could relate to and help ease them into the style and dialect of the stories to come. After the animal stories come the “fanciful” stories about magic, riddles, and tall tales. Again, this is a wise introduction to topics that may be unfamiliar to some, but are told in a recognizable way. From there, the book moves into supernatural tales. These stories border on scary, but they are digested much more easily because of the stories that have come before them. Finally, the freedom tales. The reader has likely been waiting for these, but I think it works having them at the end. They are gentle reminders of where these stories came from and the conditions that gave rise to them. However, having them at the end allowed the reader to enjoy them for what they were, without having them all appear to be about slavery. Also, knowing how all the other stories were told, with magic and riddles, it was nice to see those fanciful elements be applied to real-life conditions that the people telling them were living in.
At first, I thought the author’s notes at the end of each story were going to be distracting and not very helpful. However, the more I read, the more I would get anxious to read what she had to say, while I was reading. I found that her comments often added really interesting layers to the stories.
Labels: black history, fables, folklore, YA Lit
Here is a link to my other educational blog, with ideas for integrating new literacies and other forms of technology into the classroom.
Labels: Media Literacy
Some of the best things I've ever read have been "untraditional." The reason I mention this is because I believe that risk and voice are the most significant elements of writing that makes it interesting. However, because each person's voice and story are different for each person, there simply is not a right or wrong way to express one's ideas. I think there is a place and a time to teach specific kinds of writing, but overall, I think it is far more important to encourage general expression
Teaching risk and voice requires you to be open about how grammar is used and be flexible about how it's taught
There should be progression in how we teach grammar
Students should have a chance to go back and look at what they've written
Conferences as a means of getting to know students, guiding
Analysis: rethinking "error" helps us focus on voice and encourage risk. Also really getting on board with the concept of drafts
I don't remember having been given a lot of freedom in my writing and now I am a good academic writer, but I've rarely explored creative writing because of fear. When I've taught students writing, I often get bogged down in grammar, spelling, and punctuation. The readings really helped me see what is more important to see in student writing.
Application: how I will run conferences. work I need to do to feel more prepared to teach writing
I don't remember being given a lot of freedom in my writing development in secondary school.
Link: http://www.coolnsmart.com/, http://www.quotegarden.com/, 4000 Questions for Getting to Know Anyone and Everyone
Labels: writing
When I read the following line, my heart leapt a little: “We believe that this form of writing [timed writing assessments] should be treated as a genre that students need practice mastering” (Newkirk and Kent 66). I truly feel, after reading that line, that a majority of my anxiety over teaching writing and assessing writing has been resolved. I understand the author’s caution to be sure that the majority of time writing is not spent just on test preparation, and that it is important to stress voice and a measure of creativity, but I really relate to the idea that timed high-stakes test writing be treated separately from other forms of writing. I think that this sends the message that there is a time and a place for the considerations that go into those pieces of writing, but when we’re considering other styles, most of those conventions can be, if not ignored, at least put on the back burner. Once it is recognized that this type of writing is important, but also very specific, it gives us, as educators, the freedom to arrange it so that it does not dominate instruction of other forms of writing.
I am finding I am very drawn to the idea, also, of portfolios and grading “not just the final product […] but also the student’s writing process, growth as a writer, and commitment to his own writing development” (Dornan 188). By teaching writing to young people, we are acknowledging that they do not know how to do this themselves. They are being taught. They should be graded on the learning, not the perfecting. I have never used a portfolio in my own schooling and as I reflect on the readings about portfolios, including the other article by Richard Kent, and how I intend on using them in my classroom, I genuinely think I would have turned out to be a better writer if I had ever had experience with a writing portfolio. I have always approached school writing as something that was supposed to come out perfect the first time. The product was what mattered and so I never learned to value the process or the practice. I do not want my students to leave my class with this same mentality. I think it stifles creativity and makes students feel inadequate when they struggle with early drafts. If they think that all writing is supposed to come out neat and tidy the first time, they feel like a failure when they need to revise and revise and revise. What a shame.
http://webeasysearch.com/search/search.cgi?q=writing+contests
This is a website that directs educators to various writing contests around the country. I think that writing contests would be an interesting form of motivation for students.
Labels: writing
It's overwhelming to read so much about the teaching of writing in one sitting. There is a lot of work involved in teaching writing to high schoolers - a lot of planning, front-loading, feedback giving, and grading. However, I am particularly struck in this week's readings by some of the recurring themes: writing is hard, necessary, and the process can be varied greatly. Additionally, despite being a little overwhelmed, I am really inspired by the reading this week and anxious to get to the writing component of my job. Last week I expressed a little anxiety over teaching writing because it is not something I had previously thought much about. After attending the writing workshop today and seeing the kids there expressing themselves and expanding their awareness and really becoming more of who they are right in front of our eyes really reminded me of the power of self-expression and how essential it is to a young person's development. I am really excited to ignite insight and thoughtfulness in this way to my students, as well as explore some writing processes myself along the way!
The appendices in the Dornan book provides nice outlines for teaching some writing styles and offers the aspiring teacher a number of tips for setting up a classroom that successfully provides students with a safe, nurturing, and productive environment in which to write and think. Kent also provides many ideas for how to set up a writing schedule and a way of connecting with students through writing. I think it's always important to be supportive and encouraging to our students, regardless of the discipline, but it seems even more important in a classroom that asks students to be so candid, open, and vulnerable. In order for students to be honest and risky in their expressions it is essential for the English teacher to develop really trusting and secure relationships with their students. Even though I think it is unrealistic to put all of the suggestions and tips into practice in my own classroom, I think these readings did offer good insight into the importance of organizing the writing curriculum and establishing a comfortable, honest, and natural dialogue with the students. I believe that establishing the former makes securing the latter much easier. I agree with the authors of Within and Beyond the Writing Process when the assert that "when we write within a supportive, nurturing environment that encourages risk taking and experimentation with form, language, and ideas, we can accept error and momentary ineptitude as an inevitable part of our writing development" (Dornan 5).
The reading about audience was a bit of a struggle for me. It's difficult to digest a paper about one aspect of writing in such a formal way. I relate much more easily to the real life accounts in the textbooks and the notion that "there is no singular writing process - there are multiple processes - and the processes are recursive rather than linear" (6). While I recognize that the authors of the article were trying to dispel the idea that there is one right way to consider the audience as one writes, I still think it was reductive and oversimplified, couched in fancy language and shallow research. I prefer to think about the process and how people go about it to be an ongoing debate, the general consensus of which changes from genre to genre and topic to topic and personal preference to personal preference. I think it's dangerous to make formal prescriptions about the act of writing. If we teach students that there is a right or wrong way to consider the audience in our writing, we risk cutting off brilliant ideas due to unnecessary "fears." I do, though, expect the conversation to come up in my classroom. If there is a debate about something in the writing or literary world, I would definitely want to bring the conversation into my class and have the students participate in it.
http://mwp.umn.edu/
I chose this link because I attended the Young Writer's Conference today and was blown away by the level of involvement, reflection, and insight the students had to offer. I think the Minnesota Writing Project is really interesting and has many tools for an English teacher.
Labels: writing
I admit that when I think about my future career as a Language Arts teacher, I rarely think of myself as a writing teacher. I always picture myself teaching literature. I just haven't thought much about myself as a teacher of writing. Perhaps this is because I always felt that writing came fairly naturally to me. Additionally, I've been inclined to think of writing as a natural reaction to literature, because I am accustomed to reading book reviews and critical essays. When I do think about what has to go into writing instruction, I usually get a little panicky and stop thinking about it. This week's readings have managed to calm me down enough to reflect on how I might lead writing instruction in my classroom.
I was at first confused about, then unconvinced of, and finally warming to Romano's multi-genre assignment. I didn't really get it at first. I didn't get the assignment and really didn't get the purpose. Then, I started getting it, but thought it was a little pretentious and had little practical value. By the time I was finished reading his article, I was coming around. The thing that really resonates with me about his idea is that there is no "right" or "wrong" way to teach writing. I have always thought of writing in a language arts classroom as being all about polished critical and analytical essays. I thought about all the punctuation, grammatical, and spelling errors I was going to have to correct in my lifetime. I imagined sentence trees and explaining noun-verb agreement until the day I died. But his idea was an introduction, for me, into the idea that good writing needs to be practiced. There are millions of kinds of writing, and students should be exposed to all of them and allowed to discover which one is best for them.
http://andromeda.rutgers.edu/~jlynch/Writing/links.html
Labels: writing
