I didn’t really know what to expect with this book. This was one of my first experiences with a graphic novel and I had mixed emotions about it. I sense that I am responding to the book as much for its genre as for its content, since I am still sorting out how I feel about graphic novels. As of now, I am thinking that the graphic novel is a wonderful way to encourage reluctant readers, offers a lot of opportunity for classroom activity, and is very entertaining. However, I fear that it could also be criticized for undermining reading or seen as being condescending. A successful graphic novel can be more of a benefit for the classroom than a deterrent, so the graphic novel deserves careful treatment.
I really enjoyed the way this book intersects Chinese myth and present-day concerns. Many young people of all backgrounds tend to disregard the myths and legends of their ancestors as outdated and un-relatable. However, by presenting the Monkey King story in cartoon form and sprinkled with humor, it suddenly becomes modern and relevant. I also really like the aspects of this story that could not have been told without the illustrations, such as Jin’s transformation into Danny and Danny’s “cousin” Chin-Kee.
I struggled through the parts with Chin-Kee. Of course, I understand the use of hyperbole and irony, but it is still uncomfortable to read through such blatant stereotyping. Once, though, everything comes together in the end, I realized how effective that character was. But, again, Yang’s portrayal should be carefully dealt with in a classroom situation.
Critical Response
This book deals with themes and issues related to stereotyping and discrimination, on a personal level and in popular culture. The book begins with Chinese myth and hooks the reader with humor and action. The other two stories, of Jin and Danny, seem unrelated, both to the Monkey King story and to each other. The reader grows a little suspicious when Danny’s Chinese cousin Chin-Kee visits. The reader never sees Danny’s parents and Danny himself doesn’t appear to be Chinese, so his relation to Chin-Kee is suspect.
The dialogue and illustrations are very entertaining and engaging, even believable. The interaction between Jin and his new teacher introducing him to the classroom is very funny and the look on Timmy’s face when he raises his hand to ask about whether Chinese people eat dog or not is spot on. Frankly, it is laugh out loud funny. But the humor is, of course, tongue-in-cheek – it’s funny because it’s a little too true and we’ve all seen situations just like it. And this is where this book and books like it are so successful. They deal with serious issues without taking themselves too seriously.
The ending of the book was slightly troubling. I thought it was a little too convenient and continued to exploit a number of stereotypes, but in ways I found more difficult to explain away. For example, Wei-Chen’s transformation into a thug bothers me. However, the overall messages – accepting yourself as you are and realizing that the people you may want to be like are not worth being like – are worthy and powerful.

0 comments:
Post a Comment