Blogger Template by Blogcrowds.

I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed this story. Truth be told, I was downright inspired by this book. The other night, I was finishing Shipwreck in my apartment, wrapped in a wool blanket because it was a little chilly, trying to imagine what it must have been like to be so cold, and so wet, and so hungry for so long. A few summers ago, I spent ten days canoeing and camping in the boundary waters. At one point, we had to portage our way through muskeg – a mixture of mud and water not unlike quicksand – that came up to our waists. Through this, I had to go back and forth, carrying four canoes on my shoulders, Duluth packs, and food crates. It was unbearably hot and muggy, and you could almost not see through the black flies that were feasting on any exposed skin they could find. At the time, it was the most uncomfortable I could remember being in a long time. And that ordeal lasted all of 45 minutes. Clearly I am a huge wimp, but needless to say, I was blown away by these men’s adventure.
I am not a non-fiction fan. It’s not that I don’t like non-fiction; I do and I wish I liked it more. It’s just that I get a little bored with it. I usually feel like I am reading a textbook and while I’m reading, I find myself gazing longingly at the novels on my shelves. That being said, I am fully aware of how much non-fiction can offer and even more aware of how necessary it is to have good non-fiction in a classroom. My brother, for example, loves non-fiction and is pretty much all he reads. But he wasn’t a big reader when he was younger and I asked him about this recently. He told me that he wasn’t exposed to books he really enjoyed until he got to college. For him, reading meant novels and he was just not into them. But once he got his hands on great non-fiction, he was addicted. So, I appreciate that non-fiction is a genre that is an access point for many readers and depriving them of it when they are young would be a terrible waste.

Critical Response

Shipwreck at the Bottom of the World is a textbook example of good non-fiction (pun intended). Jennifer Armstrong has incorporated all of the elements into her story that are essential for a story to be captivating and believable. The story incorporates records from the men’s journals and is very specific with the dates things occurred and times things happened. Charts, maps, lists, and photographs bring dimension to the story and allows the readers to physically engage with it.
The opening section, “Just Imagine,” brilliantly captures the audience’s attention. The descriptions of Antarctica are vivid and convey the hostility of the land. Armstrong writes, “The ice never melts; it clings to the bottom of the world, spawning winds, storms, and weather that affects the whole planet.” Her use of words like “clings” and “spawns” articulate how violent and inhospitable the place is. The impression of this continent being at “the bottom of the world” reminds readers of its isolation, but its ability to affect the weather of the entire planet is also a reminder of its strength. Finally, this section foreshadows the events in the book. In another kind of book, the revelation that no one dies on the exploration might be a giveaway that ruins the story. But in this case, the outcome is not as important as the journey itself. An adventure story is about the adventure. Further, most readers of non-fiction adventure stories would know enough to realize that no one would be writing a book about it if it wasn’t sensational and had a miraculous ending.
In no time, Armstrong has her readers on Endurance with the men, invested in their journey. She portrays the men as immensely likeable, which it seems they truly were. Incorporating stories that reveal their characters allows the readers to become familiar in a more intimate way with them. For example, the story of how The Boss deals with the stowaway reveals him to be tough, but kind and generous. The reader is able to follow their trek using the map at the beginning of the book and anticipate what might happen next by comparing dates on the map with the dates in the story. The reader is engaged and invested.
The pictures in this book really enhanced the reading experience. The pictures themselves were often startlingly beautiful and really capture the stark beauty and isolation of Antarctica. The reader can really close their eyes and try to imagine this ordeal. Especially pictures of the various camps, how the stoves were set up, how the ice latched onto them, and how they latched onto the boats as they dragged them through the ice, allow the reader to picture things that would otherwise be difficult to imagine. The book could have included a few pictures or diagrams of how the floes and bergs moved and swelled and how the ice managed to crush Endurance. For someone not familiar with how those things work, a visual aid would be helpful.
Overall, this book nicely captures an amazing adventure, but is also a powerful example of leadership, teamwork, endurance, bravery, and patience. It is not just an engaging story, but provides readers with valuable life lessons.

1 comments:

I love how you connect this book to your personal experience when canoeing. It is so true that we think we are enduring the worst possible thing and then when we compare it to someone else's ordeal, we realize what whimps we really are. I personally avoid most camping experiences for this very reason. Despite the fact that I try to avoid "roughing it," I really enjoyed this book. While I found the beginning to be too textbook for my taste, I really enjoyed the second half of the book when the author changed to a more narrative style. From that point on, I was a vested reader in finding out how the men managed to survive their ordeal. I also appreciate what you wrote about different readers needing access to different types of reading materials. It is always good to be reminded that there are lots of different kinds of readers in our classrooms and it is our responsibility to help them to find materials that will strike an interest in them.

November 10, 2010 at 6:36 AM  

Newer Post Older Post Home